SIP in equity vs debt: Understanding the difference with an SIP calculator

Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) combine affordability with ease of investing, making them a convenient way to invest in mutual funds. However, choosing which type of fund to invest in – equity, debt or hybrid – can be confusing. This is because different schemes have varying risk levels and return potential.

An SIP calculator can help make this decision easier, showing you what you could potentially earn from an investment. This can help you decide the avenue that may be suitable for your goals. This article will explain in detail how to use an SIP calculator to choose between equity and debt mutual funds.

What is an SIP?

SIP, or Systematic Investment Plan, is a method of investing in mutual funds by regularly contributing a fixed amount. This can be weekly, monthly, quarterly, etc. SIP investment offers the benefit of disciplined investing and enable you to invest an amount you are comfortable with – the minimum investment amount starts at Rs 100 to Rs 500. It also encourages discipline and saves investors the hassle of trying to accurately time an unpredictable market, because investments happen at a fixed schedule irrespective of market conditions. Over the long term, this typically tends to smooth out the average cost of the investment and mitigate the impact of market volatility.

Equity vs debt funds: Key differences

Based on the nature of the securities they invest in, mutual funds can broadly be classified into equity, debt and hybrid (which are a combination of both). Here’s a comparison between equity and debt funds.

1. Nature of investment

    • Equity funds: Invest in stocks or equities of companies.
    • Debt funds: Invest in fixed-income securities such as bonds, government securities, and treasury bills.

2. Risk level

    • Equity funds: Entail higher risk because of market volatility. Suitable for investors with a high-risk appetite and a long investment horizon.
    • Debt funds: Typically carry low or moderate risk as they invest in fixed-income instruments. Suitable for conservative investors who prioritise risk mitigation over return potential.

3.  Return potential

    • Equity funds: Potential for high returns in the long term. However, returns can be unpredictable due to market fluctuations.
    • Debt funds: Has relatively stable return potential because earnings are in the form of interest payments and principal repayment at maturity.

4. Investment horizon

    • Equity funds: Suited for long-term goals like retirement or children’s education due to their growth potential over time.
    • Debt funds: Suitable for short to medium-term goals such as buying a car or building an emergency fund.

The choice between equity and debt investments, therefore, depends on your goal amount, risk appetite, investment horizon, and the return potential you seek. An SIP calculator can aid the decision. This easy-to-use tool helps you estimate the future value of your investments based on the amount, duration, and expected rate of return. With this information, you can plan your investment strategy and identify a suitable investment avenue.

Do keep in mind, however, that equity investments are typically suitable for longer terms because markets can be very volatile in the short term, so returns can fluctuate vastly from expectations. Over a longer horizon, however, markets have historically moved upward.

How to use SIP calculator for choosing between equity and debt funds

1. Define your financial goals

Determine the purpose of your investment. Possible goals could include retirement planning, buying a house, or financing higher education. Your goals will influence whether you should lean towards equity or debt investments.

2. Assess your risk tolerance

Understand your risk appetite. Equity investments are generally more volatile and suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance, while debt investments are typically relatively stable and may be suitable for conservative investors.

3. Input the investment details

On the online SIP calculator, enter the following details:

  • Monthly investment amount
  • Investment duration
  • Expected rate of return.

4. Calculate for equity investments

Enter the expected rate of return for equity investments (for example., 12%). The SIP calculator will provide you with the estimated future value of your equity investments.

5. Calculate for debt investments

Similarly, enter the expected rate of return for debt investments (for example, 6.5%). The SIP calculator will show the estimated future value of your debt investments.

6. Compare the results

Analyse the results from the SIP calculator for both equity and debt investments. Compare the future values to see which type of investment aligns better with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

7. Consider hybrid funds

If you find it difficult to choose between equity and debt, consider hybrid funds, which invest in a mix of both. Use the SIP calculator to evaluate the performance of the hybrid fund category you are interested in, based on their historical returns.

Example calculation

Let’s consider an example to illustrate this process. However, keep in mind that these calculations assume a fixed and consistent rate of return. In reality, returns can fluctuate and are not guaranteed.

  • Monthly investment: Rs. 10,000
  • Investment duration: 10 years
  • Expected rate of return for equity: 12%
  • Expected rate of return for debt: 7%

Equity calculation

  • Monthly investment: Rs. 10,000
  • Duration: 10 years
  • Rate of return: 12%

Using the SIP calculator:

  • Future Value = Rs. 23,23,391

Debt investment calculation

  • Monthly investment: Rs. 10,000
  • Duration: 10 years (120 months)
  • Rate of return: 7%

Using the SIP calculator:

  • Future value = Rs. 17,25,416

As this example shows, equity investments have the potential to yield higher returns than debt, but the investment horizon and risk appetite are vital factors for consideration. Because of the volatility of the markets, equity investments may not be suitable for short-term goals. An economic downturn or prolonged bear market may result in low or even negative returns. A long investment horizon can mitigate risk and optimise return potential for equities as it can tide over short-term volatility. However, investors will still need to be comfortable with risk to invest in equity funds.

Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme-related documents carefully.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Privacy & Cookies Policy